October 19, 2006

C.A.R. says 2007 will see a -2% Drop in California. Does This Feel like a 2% Yearly Drop?



This quote from the L.A. Times article today:

“Now, the housing boom is over, with the slowdown expected to continue next year, according to a new forecast by the state's real estate agents. The median price of an existing California home will decline 2% to $550,000 in 2007 from a projected median price of $561,000 this year, according to the California Assn. of Realtors. Sales are projected to decline 7% to 447,500 units from 481,200 this year.”

Okay, for one thing the C.A.R. has already demonstrated that they were wrong with their $561,000 prediction so why in the world are we to believe their rosy colored scenario of a 2 percent drop in 2007? They are predicting a moderate correction of $11,000 across the state of California. In addition, they are predicting sales dropping off by 7 percent. Are we following two different markets or are we drinking from two different data fountains? For one, sales are down a whopping 30% across the state from last year according to DataQuick. In addition, that two percent drop has already occurred! For example, Southern California has already seen a 2% drop since the peak in June 2006 of $493,000; by the way, we currently stand at $484,000 for those keeping track. For one, the C.A.R. will be wrong since they predicted a double-digit gain this year for the state when most likely, we will hit zero percent or even negative territory by year end. Great source of unbiased information. Did I mention they are an association of agents?

So you want to investigate yourself? You say, this isn’t that bad right? Take a look at ZipRealty. They list 116,391 properties in the Greater L.A. area for sale. Want to guess how many are reduced listings? 48,136! In other words, 41 percent of L.A. county listings have been reduced or "cut" as I like to say. In addition, keep in mind this does not factor in listings that have expired or properties that have been taken off the market. What is also happening is agents are removing properties from the MLS and simply relisting them. So the 41 percent number is a low-ball number.

Now ask yourself this simple question: if the market was so hot why would nearly half of all listings be reduced? Not only that, why have sales dropped 30 percent from last year? Do these numbers line up with the C.A.R.’s glorious predictions?

13 Comments:

bubble_watcher said...

San Diego, -6.6% YOY (Year over Year)
Los Angeles, -5.5% YOY
Newport Beach, -3.7% YOY
Orange County, -3.1% (six months)
Riverside, -4.1% (six months)
Sacramento, -5.3% YOY
San Francisco, +3.3% YOY
San Jose, -1.0% (six months)

[Link]

Dr Housing Bubble said...

The one thing about HousingTracker that I did not like before is that they used broad metropolitan areas and based much of their information on pure asking price. I recently saw that they will be using Census MSA areas which should help on some of their stats. If you notice, the median asking prices on HousingTracker will always be overly high and optimistic. The best tracking that I have found was via a multiple prong approach.

1. Check to see recent sales prices on the home in question (www.zillow.com)
2. Check ZipRealty and use the map feature to see comparable area sales (www.ziprealty.com)
3. Check with DataQuick to see median prices for your zipcode (www.dqnews.com)
4. Aggregate the information and do a basic rental market survey. Data can be gathered via the L.A. Times or any other local source.
5. Go to Census.gov to verify local median family income in area (www.census.gov)

I think this is the best way to get a general sense of the current market value in the area. In addition, this should provide you a good sense of whether prices are out of whack with market fundamentals.

jrinlv said...

Regarding the misinformation from C.A.R on the 2007 California housing drop: does someone actually contact the newspaper (L.A. Times) and C.A.R. with these concerns or do these issues and concerns only remain on this website? Thanks for taking the time and energy to produce and maintain this website!!

Dr Housing Bubble said...

jrinlv said:

"Regarding the misinformation from C.A.R on the 2007 California housing drop: does someone actually contact the newspaper (L.A. Times) and C.A.R. with these concerns or do these issues and concerns only remain on this website?"

I've e-mailed them a few times regarding this but of course, the C.A.R. is welcome to make any predictions they like. They can declare prices will zoom 200% next year and the next week discuss how they knew a 10% drop would happen. It is the nature of the game. The same rights are given to us to use our judgment and determine what we think will happen in one, two, or even ten years. Hopefully people take this information into account and realize real estate goes in cycles. On one of my links, there is a UC professor that shows real estate cycles dating back to the 1800s. Rather enlightening. Thanks for reading!

channel download psp rssybcgfy said...

I went to Orange County Real Estate So I visited this site and I could not find a phone # but...

Anonymous said...

Hello. Enjoyed your blog. I like the design and you have great content. Keep up the good work.

To see reviews of the Online Dating Sites please visit this site.

John Tiniakos said...

Hey nice blog.

For great articles on dating, relationship and romance tips please visit my site at Online Dating Sites blog

Anonymous said...

I was looking at all the Real estate Signs California I happened to find the abslote best price in california with this company... Great service...

Anonymous said...

charlottesville real estate Was the Site I arrived at when I was offered the best real estate deal in my life you must contact this company.

Anonymous said...

I recently found real estate signs from DEESIGN, The Best value and customer experience a realtor will ever have, hands down.

Anonymous said...

Newport beach real estate The Most Powerful real estate source for california real estate on the net.











Bye the way great blog

Anonymous said...

Orange County SEO Companies The First time I called Atomic SEO, I was impressed with the level of expertise that I had percieved. They Got me Results and thats all I asked for so in Orange County and you need seo these are the guys to go too.

seo toolsvltg8u said...

real estate investment The Most Powerful Real Estate Investment company on the planet.

real estate investment education will make your wildest dreams come true.


real estate investment clubs can be found here.